Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

Silent Night, from hymn to hype

 

I knew I was overtired recently when I found myself getting teary watching a Qantas ad. But the truth is, modern advertisements are fuelled by brilliantly creative people, and some are masterpieces of emotional manipulation. Frequently this applies to products or services you’d rather not be connected to, (Sportsbet anyone?) but nonetheless find yourself entertained, moved and inspired by productions that could pass as award-winning short films. 

The annual Christmas ad for Austria’s financial services provider, Erste, is an example of this and an anticipated event watched by millions of people — the agency that produces these annual campaigns has won over 50 industry awards for them since 2018. This year the focus is on the most recorded Christmas song in history, Silent Night

The ad tells the story of the beloved Christmas carol, beginning with its composition by the young priest Joseph Mohr in 1818. In the shadow of the Napoleonic wars, and the ensuing poverty that surrounded him, on Christmas Eve Mohr presented the lyrics to his composer friend Franz Xaver Gruber, who came up with the melody. That night it was played in St Nicholas church north of Salzburg, to the wonderment of those gathered. 

Or so the story goes. 

It is all captured magnificently by the Erste ad, which then tracks the song’s journey through time, being played by a Tyrolean singing group for King Franz I of Austria in 1822, then by Reginald Fessenden’s violin during the very first broadcast of radio entertainment in America in 1906. Next, the pathos of the trenches of WWI with British and German troops singing it is given a haunting run, followed by astronauts of ‘Skylab 4’ orbiting earth in 1973. Moving to a contemporary setting on a beach, a guitar player serenades his friends, before we see a mother nursing her baby to sleep, and a school kid’s Christmas concert.

‘Silent Night’ has done the rounds and captured here is the sense of longing this carol always manages to evoke. The contrast of the beautiful simplicity of the song set against the vicissitudes of the human drama is captivating.  

Which is why the end of this ad is such a travesty! With closing vision overlooking the snow-covered Austrian village of Joseph Mohr, these words appear on the screen:  

 

‘Your spark can light up the world. Believe in yourself. Believe in Christmas.’

 

The idea is that a simple action of one person can bring hope to others and add light to their world. Fair enough. It’s true that Joseph Mohr’s musical gesture has made a big impact in ‘lighting up the world’ but it’s comical to link the rural priest’s message to the 21st Century mantra of a generation brought up on the self-esteem movement: ‘believe in yourself’. That would have been incomprehensible to him. Mohr was pointing to, and drawing inspiration from, a story outside of himself where he could discover wonder, awe and beauty. 

 


 

Simon Smart is the Executive Director of the Centre for Public Christianity and the host of Life & Faith podcast.

 

Topic tags: Simon Smart, Christmas, Advertising, Silent Night

 

 

submit a comment

Existing comments

I think you hit the nail square on its head there, Simon. Christianity is not about self-fulfilment, although, paradoxically, there are many deeply fulfilled Christians. 'Silent Night' engenders a sense of awe and of wonder. It should not be manipulated, but it is. A very wise Indonesian once said, and this was in the 1970s, that advertising copywriters were the black magicians of the modern world.


Edward Fido | 19 December 2024  

Similar Articles

Books, screens, and holiday dreams

  • Juliette Hughes
  • 18 December 2024

In a year defined by uneven cultural offerings, books stood tall while cinema faltered and television treaded water. From Alexander Armstrong’s enchanting Evenfall to Patricia Briggs’ mystical Winter Lost, the literary landscape offered gems aplenty. Meanwhile, Netflix’s Mary proved a thunderous flop, and Barbie charmed in pink. Let the debates begin.

READ MORE

A Man on the Inside asks: What does it mean to stay connected as we age?

  • Daniel Herborn
  • 18 December 2024

In A Man on the Inside, Ted Danson’s Charles brings wit and warmth to a retirement home whodunit with a poignant edge. Created by Mike Schur (The Good Place), this Netflix gem artfully blends comedy, mystery, and social commentary, exploring the ache of loss, the joy of purpose, and the profound value of connection.

READ MORE
Join the conversation. Sign up for our free weekly newsletter  Subscribe