It was reported recently that the Vatican has brought its work practices up to date. Employees must now clock in, and will be offered incentive payments based on performance.
The news conjured a comic vision of cardinals in full regalia sweeping punctiliously to the time clock, and of a torrent of Papal Bulls, Encyclicals and Motibus Propriis flooding down the printing press. Pope John XXIII's reply to a visitor who asked how many people worked in the Vatican was again much quoted. 'About half', he said.
Schadenfreude, natural in response to big bureaucracies, but good humoured as you might expect. All of us would like to see bureaucracies, other than the tax office, work more efficiently. But the introduction of incentive payments raises questions, particularly at a time when we see that these devices, when used by the masters of the universe, have set fire to their creation.
At the top end of town, incentive payments have been monstrous and their consequences disastrous. They have encouraged executives to increase short-term profit by reducing expenditure on activities central to the firm's health and by taking on heavy debt. When the companies collapsed, the executives shamelessly kept the loot. Incentive payments have been an instrument of greed.
It would be wrong to argue that incentive payments inevitably lead to this spectacularly destructive form of greed. But they generally encourage greed by embodying a venal view of the relations involved in work. Incentive payments, for example, assume that our willingness to work hard will vary in direct proportion to the remuneration we receive. The more money we get, the harder we will work; the more money we offer, the better the workers we shall find. The honey of money alone attracts worker ants to leave their holes.
When financial reward is so exalted, the other significant rewards of work are downplayed. Yet these are as central to motivation of workers and to the health of the enterprise as is its level of profit. If we have pride in the organisation in which we work because it is honest and helpful in its relations with its suppliers and clients, because relations between workers are companionable, or because the services that it provides are helpful to society, we may find ourselves more strongly motivated by these blessings than by any promise of more payment. We may also be drawn to work hard because our workplace