Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

ARTS AND CULTURE

The trouble with JK Rowling

  • 26 November 2018
Crimes of Grindelwald was a fantastic masterclass in screenwriting for authors — it showed exactly what not to do. Crimes of Grindelwald is the second instalment of the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them franchise, primarily focused on the battle between Gellert Grindelwald (Johnny Depp) and Albus Dumbledore (Jude Law) — a sort of Hitler/Churchill-esque match up with the final battle ending in 1945.

The main story follows Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne) who is requested by Dumbledore to go to Paris and find Credence (Ezra Miller) before Grindelwald does, because Credence possesses an obscurus — a sort of ball of evil magical energy with massive destructive powers.

This is the first time so many characters with major screen time have been from diverse backgrounds in a Harry Potter film. But it’s not enough to just plonk them into an already bursting script. For example: casting a Korean actress to play Nagini, an 'Indonesian' (according to JK Rowling) creature that was originally found in Indian mythology points to the ham-fisted attempts at paying lip service to JK Rowling’s self-professed liberal ideology — the obvious errors highlight how much the showrunners don’t care about doing their research properly.

And even when you get past the obvious issues with this characterisation, Nagini herself does nothing except act as window dressing, and as a nod to Harry Potter fans, that yes, that snake Voldemort turns into a horcrux was an Asian woman once.

JK Rowling has been criticised many times over her treatment of minorities — saying Dumbledore is gay and Anthony Goldstein (a minor Harry Potter character) was actually Jewish post the books’ publication. It felt like JK Rowling was taking credit for something she’d never actually done.

Fantastic Beasts feels like she’s trying to fix this perception — albeit in the clumsiest way imaginable. New characters like Leta Lestrange (Zoe Kravitz), Nagini (Claudia Kim) and Yusuf Kama (William Nadylam) are all a healthy departure from Harry Potter’s homogenous cast and Dumbledore is finally explicitly shown to be gay on screen, but this is where the faint praise ends and the spoilers begin.

Leta Lestrange is the most fleshed out new character of colour. An enormous amount of time is filled with her backstory, both her romantic entanglements with the Scamanders and her connections to Credence and Dumbledore. The problem is that inclusion of a female character of colour fails to be progressive when all of these character
Forgot your password?
Subscribe