A- A A+

Luckily for Australia, winning really isn't everything

9 Comments
Michael McVeigh |  21 August 2016

 

If this Olympic Games leaves us with any legacy, let it be that the phrase 'podium pants' now enters the lexicon.

xxxxxThe Irish brothers Gary and Paul O'Donovan might have only taken home the silver medal, but they've become global stars thanks to the hilarious interviews they've been giving after their event in Rio, from going into unnecessary detail about the process of giving urine samples, to expressing their disappointment about not being back at the pub at home in Skibbereen.

In fact, most of my favourite moments at the Olympic Games this year have been from 'losers' — presuming you can really apply that label to anyone who's reached the elite level of a global sport.

Australian runner Ella Nelson was informed in a live TV interview that she'd missed out on qualifying for the 200m final by 0.1 of a second. You can see the disappointment flash across her face in the video but then moments later she recovers as she takes in the whole moment.

'I just ran a PB (personal best) at the Olympic Games,' she says. 'I couldn't have asked for a better 2016. I hate that it's one hundredth ... but I'm so happy. How can I not be?'

These moments provide a fascinating contrast to the columns that have been appearing in the media following what has been a disappointing Olympics in terms of medals success.

Australia appears likely to fall well short of its pre-games medal target of 13 gold medals, with many of its more fancied contenders failing to live up to the high public expectations. In fact, Australia looks like not even reaching its medal total for the London Olympics (35 medals), which was the country's worst performance in 20 years.

Apart from the women's rugby sevens and the men's basketball team, Australia's performances in team sports have been disastrous, with teams in rugby, hockey, basketball and soccer dropping out in early rounds. Swimmers and cyclists and other athletes who had previously had success in world championships have failed to win medals.

 

"How inspired does a local butcher get when they see the little kid who used to come into the shop with her parents competing in the judo tournament? How do you put a financial price on these outcomes?"

 

Criticisms have been raised about the government's Winning Edge funding strategy, which has seen money poured into elite sports where Australia has traditionally been most successful or where medals seemed most likely. It has seen increased funding directed into 14 Olympic sports, including basketball, cycling, diving and shooting.

This approach to funding inevitably leads people to calculate whether Australia has received 'value for money' for its investments. If a gold medal represents such value, then any achievement that doesn't end up in gold feels like money squandered. It might be well and good for an athlete to talk about achieving a 'personal best', but then the inevitable response is, 'Do taxpayers fund people to compete only against themselves?'

While the mercenary response to our games efforts is an inevitable consequence of our approach to funding mostly those with a chance of achieving medals, it doesn't necessarily have much to do with what people actually get out of watching or being part of the Olympics. There's another factor in the equation, a human factor, that's a lot harder to put a monetary value on and a lot harder to measure.

How much of a lift to the spirit does a school get when it watches one of its recent graduates compete in the track cycling against the best in the world? How inspired does a local butcher get when they see the little kid who used to come into the shop with her parents competing in the judo tournament? How proud do Ella Nelson's parents and friends feel about the way she conducted herself after her event? How do you put a financial price on these outcomes?

I'm not saying that, in a limited funding picture, there shouldn't be some consideration given to directing so much money to elite sport over grassroots competitions. I'm also happy to concede that we can be just as inspired by the stories and examples of overseas athletes as we can be by Australians. I'm just wondering if perhaps this focus on value for our investment has somewhat overshadowed the deeper value of having Australians striving to be part of this gathering of the world's greatest athletes.

As so many of the 'losers' at the Olympics have shown, in the grace and humour of their responses to failure, it's not winning that makes a person great. Indeed, a few of the winners at this games haven't acted like great people outside the competitive arena. What draws people to a person, what will make them cheer for that person even when they've fallen down and injured themselves and all that's left is to stumble across the line, is that we see something of ourselves in their efforts. Their small victories are our small victories.

If we're going to review where we direct our Olympic funding, perhaps we should look less at those people who are the best chance for medals, and more at those people who are most likely to inspire us with their efforts. Even if that's a lot more difficult to measure.

 


Michael McVeighMichael McVeigh is the editor of Australian Catholics magazine and senior editor at Jesuit Communications.

 



Comments

Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Proud of cousin Scott Bowden for his achievement getting to Rio and taking part in mountain bike racing. The world's a big place and we're part of it.

Mary-Anne Johnson 22 August 2016

Usually, I watch the Olympics with rapt attention. Not this time though, and not due to lack of interest but circumstance. Australia, per capita, has produced many great sports people This is a personal assessment but Don Bradman and Rod Laver spring to mind as sportsmen who were world-best and achieved that due, primarily, to great love for their sport and skills honed by dedication springing from that love. Temperament is always a key factor in sporting success and I like to think that, even if great success had not come their way, they would have been happy playing their sport on a Saturday arvo at the local cricket ground or tennis courts. Money cannot buy that. Congrats. to all athletes who competed at Rio and enjoy the fact you got there!

Pam 22 August 2016

The human body is a wonderful creation. What joy and admiration it inspires when we see it strive to jump higher, run faster, be stronger! And what a thrill it is to see men and women in the spirit of honest contest spur one another on in their striving. But - there is always a 'but' where human affairs are concerned - what happens when this contest is commercialised, politicised, becomes a platform for vainglory and chauvinism? In the Rio games there were humble winners, gallant losers and a few ne'er-do-wells (even if they did win gold medals. But for me a highlight was the way the Fiji Rugby Sevens team knelt on the winners podium to receive their gold medals. And in their interviews unashamedly, indeed quite without pretence, thanked God, their coach, and their families for their success. In such a moment the spirit that blows life into the body was made manifest. Bula Bula Fiji!

Uncle Pat 22 August 2016

So glad to see your use of apostrophes whenever you discussed winners and losers. Really all are 'winners' and 'losers.' A 'winner' can only be so because other competitors of elite standard in their event competed against them. As you quite rightly suggest these athletes are Olympians: the best their country could send having met qualifying times/ distances etc. Let us never forget that. I liked the example you chose of an athlete missing out by 1/100th of a second. Really? I would apply the same thinking to someone who misses gold by that margin too. Sometimes a frenzied media get it so wrong.

Ern Azzopardi 22 August 2016

I must admit I did not follow the Olympics very much at all this time but I was so happy for the athletes who had the chance to complete against the world's best-hopefully without having to complete against those who had the assistance of doping. What really irritates me very much is the idiotic people- so called experts who claim from their easy chairs that we failed to win our rightful quota of medals . I'd like to see them have a go ! Good on our boys and girls , you should be proud that you actually got to Rio, that is a reward in its own right.

Gavin 22 August 2016

Firstly the Olympics are games. However the integrity of the organization its accountability and performance defy rational assessment. The whole system si scammed to excess. Secondly if you are always going to fund on the measurable outcomes, as the article suggests, you will have to look for numbers. At least in this accountancy led world. Often the numbers are the worst indicator or criterion. Thirdly if you want success you ought fund the media. They make so much of the play. Fourthly why not fund more deserving causes?

Michael D. Breen 22 August 2016

Why do we spend so much time and money staging the Olympics every four years? If we want to know who is highest, fastest etc, why not just have a formal collation of annual results for each athlete or team? Of course it's because the Games are about so much more than this. It's about getting together in peace, showing off together, demonstrating beauty together. Our world is falling apart again, but the Olympic event is one of the things that can bind us together. As long as we don't let it become a triumph for individualism....

Joan Seymour 22 August 2016

Money cant by the wonderful lessons and messages all athletes send to the world - their message is not measured by gold, silver or bronze medals - they have send a message to the world - all nations can come together in peace - and we should all stand up and applaud them all - and be thankful they are all safe - two things money can never buy - example of friendship, peace and comradeship amongst all nations - I salute them all including the greatest Olympian of all times Michael Phelps - hopefully world leaders will learn from the lessons displayed by the youth of the world

Brenda Coughlan 23 August 2016

I like sport and have been brought up in a very sporty family. I like the Olympics, but not the expectations many have or the massive over funding we give to its preparation. I think sports people should be charged and have HECS as other students do. I want the money more fairly distributed, so more money on the ground level, so all Australians can benefit from sporting skills. I don't care about medals, but love good sporting behaviour.

Cate 29 August 2016

Similar articles

A society that forgives wins

11 Comments
Andrew Hamilton | 25 August 2016

Russia's Yuliya Efimova looks on as America's Lilly King celebrates winning the women's 100m breaststrokeAlmost all public conversation quickly turns to transgressors. Olympic competitors growled about proven and suspect drug users. Many wanted people found to have used drugs shamed and shunned. This insistence that transgressors should definitively lose their good name and the right to participate is not confined to sport. If inflexibility and exclusion become the rule in dealing with aberrant speech or behaviour we find unacceptable, they will impose heavy burdens on individuals and society.


The world we choose to live in

5 Comments
Jim McDermott | 24 August 2016

Stylised Trump portraitMaybe standing there we weren't afraid about the fight that was happening across the street, but the fraying at the edges that it represents, the insecurity that the gospel both of Trump and against Trump seems to be creating in our society. It echoes the insecurity we hear in the Brexit vote, and the treatment of both ethnic British citizens and immigrants that followed. Likewise, the resurrection of Pauline Hanson and her One Nation party. None of it sounds good and where is it all going?


The cost so far of Filipinos' gamble on thug rule

13 Comments
Fatima Measham | 18 August 2016

DuterteI fret more than ever for friends and family in the Philippines. If life is so expendable, who can be safe? What if my brother-in-law is mistakenly identified as a drug 'pusher'? What if my dad goes to a cockfight and armed vigilantes do a drive-by? It is disheartening that many Filipinos seem to approve of Duterte's methods. This is the purge many had wanted. They see the current campaign as a necessary, painful transition to better things. They are wrong. Nothing personal, just history.


Mack Horton vs the People's Republic of China

3 Comments
Jeremy Clarke | 17 August 2016

Sun YangHorton desired to highlight the need for more stringent application of doping policies but in the process he enabled Chinese nationalists to bolster their inflated national pride, at his and Australia's expense. That he used his concern about drug use as a competitive tactic lessened its effectiveness, and only enabled Chinese nationalists to once more don the mantle of victim. Any chance for reform around issues like drugs in sport got caught in the wake of wounded egos and jingoistic pride.


Recent reflections on Iraq War ignore key ethical questions

2 Comments
Andrew Hamilton | 10 August 2016

Tony Blair and George W. BushThe recent Chilcot report on British participation in the Iraq War elicited embarrassing responses by British and Australian leaders and apologists of the time. Specious justifications were accompanied by a failure to take responsibility. The defects of the invasion and the moral irresponsibility of those who collaborated in it did not flow solely from its procedural inadequacies. The crudity now attributed to Donald Trump and his obiter dicta on war flourished before him among Washington insiders.