A- A A+

The beloved countries are still crying

Andrew Hamilton |  22 August 2017


Seventy years ago Alan Paton wrote Cry the Beloved Country. His novel opened many Australians’ eyes to the wounded South Africa that lay behind its colonial surface. His elegiac conclusion was prescient of the two generations that followed.

xxxxx'Cry, the beloved country, for the unborn child that is the inheritor of our fear. Let him not love the earth too deeply. Let him not laugh too gladly when the water runs through his fingers, nor stand too silent when the setting sun makes red the veld with fire. Let him not be too moved when the birds of his land are singing, nor give too much of his heart to a mountain or a valley. For fear will rob him of all if he gives too much.'

What lay ahead was 50 years in which fear built fences between races, hammered laws into trenches to trap transgressors, locked freedom behind armour plate. Fear made people focus on the possessions they could lose and blinded them to the possibilities of the world in which they lived and the graciousness of the peoples with which they shared it. They lived encaged.      

The brave who had stood silent in the flaring sunset, tried to open the eyes of their people. Writers represented their world but it was not recognised. Critics denounced the injustice, and they were exiled. Thinkers proposed better policies and they were ignored.

Generous people were compassionate and they were mocked. Insurgents rose in protest and they were jailed. The darkness put out the light for longer than their lifespan. And yet they persisted.

This week is 103rd World Week of Migrants and Refugees (21-27 August). It focuses on refugee children around the world. In Australia, as elsewhere in the world, fear rules just as it did in South Africa.

We have sent ships to push them back, dumped them on remote islands, imprisoned and neglected them, shaped laws to beat them with, made compassion criminal, and caricatured their religions. And the fortress of fear keeps strengthening its battlements.

Over the last 40 years many Australians have visited, fed and clothed refugees, dreamed of a more welcoming society, proposed better policies, come together in marches, and collected alms. Year by year brief periods of sunshine have been followed by heavier storm.


"The treatment of refugees has become more brutal, their sufferings have grown and their protection under the rule of law has been shredded."


The treatment of refugees has become more brutal, their sufferings have grown and their protection under the rule of law has been shredded. Internationally, refugee organisations, founded in the hope of soon being redundant, now face an avalanche of refugees. Nations that once offered hospitality to refugees are now investing their resources in exacerbating the conflicts that produce refugees. Fear has made a desert.

In such times it is easy to cede the struggle, give in to fear. The South African experience encourages endurance beyond one’s lifetime. So does the annual Migrant and Refugee Week. It invites us to attend to the small fidelities of visiting, caring for and respecting refugees, remembering the lives that fear has scarred, and calling for a better way.

It invites us also to dream of a world where people can laugh, stand silently, be moved and give their hearts, free from fear.

It is no accident that in such a fearful world for refugees Pope Francis, like Alan Paton, focuses on vulnerable children. His appeal is practical.

I ask everyone to take care of the young, who in a threefold way are defenceless: they are children, they are foreigners, and they have no means to protect themselves. I ask everyone to help those who, for various reasons, are forced to live far from their homeland and are separated from their families.

To see the world freshly through the eyes of children, before they have learned to fear, enables us to smell the foetid world that fear has built. It enlivens us to work that refugee children, foreign and unprotected, may find a world in which they can play unafraid.  

Children make a nonsense of exceptionless rules, locked gates, detention centres, watertight policies, the brassy monuments that fear builds. They have a right to give their whole heart to mountains and valleys where they may freely roam. They mark out our task: to move our nation from fear to hospitality.


Andrew HamiltonAndrew Hamilton is consulting editor of Eureka Street.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

If you want to create a new concept called 'economic refugee', by all means argue for popular consent for it and change the migration laws accordingly. However, as the current rules say that a refugee is a person fleeing political persecution, shoehorning 'economic refugees' into a category that does not describe them is not serving truth. The difference between apartheid South Africa and Australia is the difference between accommodating a finite number of fellow citizens with some multiple of five loaves and two fish and accommodating an infinite number of foreigners with the same multiple.

Roy Chen Yee 21 August 2017

Australia has rightly been condemned for it's lack of human rights for the asylum seekers who have been sent to off-shore 'hell holes' for over 4 years now. Seven have already died and they are all now psychologically damaged for life. The Coalition and Labor are playing politics with the lives of desperate people. The boats have stopped. Our political leaders should both acknowledge the cruelty of this incompassionate biparstisan policy, and bring these desperate people to Australia.

Grant Allen 22 August 2017

Roy, would you care to expand on the final sentence of your 21 August message because I find the loaves and fishes stuff and the infinite number of foreigners hard to follow. Simple words for a simple fellow please. I thought apartheid South Africa was about maintaining a privileged minority in economic, political and social power and control at the expense of the majority of the population for as long as possible, until internal and external pressures forced the inevitable change. Am I wrong?

Brett 22 August 2017

According to some respected contemporary commentators in South Africa the future of that country is not looking rosy and they fear it might be breaking down. Refugees normally come from nations which are breaking down in some way or other. I believe famine and war are causing many Africans to seek a better life elsewhere. Sadly, Europe, where most of them are/were bound, is stretched to the limit in taking and absorbing them. Their sheer numbers can be seen as a mass migration. What now? I think the most effective action would be to attempt to assist them in their countries of origin so they don't have to migrate and be unwanted refugees. I remember seeing on the 7.30 Report on the ABC, a piece about a talented young Syriac Christian refugee in the Lebanon, who, with his family, had applied to come here as refugees and were rejected. Why was not explained. He still has relatives who have remained behind in Syria. Could he return there? Finland did accept some Middle Eastern refugees who, when it was deemed safe for them to return to their countries of origin, were returned. This is a technically insuperable problem. We certainly need to treat refugees better and the offshore solution is barbaric. Where to now?

Edward Fido 23 August 2017

Brett.. Apartheid was much more than a system to maintain a privileged minority in economic privilege and enforce the delusion of white supremacy. It has its origins in the fundamentalist, Calvinist interpretation of the Old Testament account in Genesis. Gain was exiled from the Garden of Eden for murdering his brother Abel. He is the earliest recorded Middle Eastern refugee who settled in North Africa in the Land of Nod. The people of the tribe established in Nod were Black and were considered to be the labourers, slaves or servants of others, the retributive punishment for Cain's murderous activity. The white Calvinists of South Africa considered all blacks inferior in the eyes of their God as remnants or descendants of the tribe of Nod established by Cain. Over the millennia, belief has been the greatest destroyer of Humanity and Apartheid is one of the best examples of the poison of fundamentalist interpretation of "the word of God". I would have thought the New Testament is the scripture that should have the major influence as "the word of God" rather than the metaphorical ancients' fanciful explanations of the world around them. It wasn't beyond Jesus of Nazareth to criticise the interpretations of the scriptures by the people of his time.

john frawley 23 August 2017

Beautifully written Andy. Thank you for reminding us to view this desperate situation through the eyes of children, the most innocent and vulnerable yet our best hope and means of seeing a way through the worldwide dilemma of displaced people.

Anne Doyle 24 August 2017

It is sad but true that, "The treatment of refugees has become more brutal, their sufferings have grown and their protection under the rule of law has been shredded." These are dark days for those of us who value compassion and love. Thank you, Andrew, for such a timely and truthful article.

robert van zetten 24 August 2017

Andrew, Thanks for your powerful, poetic and loving insights into an ongoing crime, sin and shameful disregard for the lives of those who claim the same humanity, breathe the same air and bleed through the same veins as do we. I remember Robert Kennedy's "every time someone stands up for an ideal, strikes out against an injustice "

Kevin Dance 25 August 2017

Well put Andrew. Not withstanding the complexities of our human condition, of our fear based apartheid - of us and them. Be we churched or unchurched. A disposition, it would seem 'we will always have with us', in a spirituality based on 'our found state', of a dualistic world view. However, I find your 'Trust and belief in Hope', inspirational, most timely and encouraging. And may I add, most Prophetic, uplifting and inclusive. That, in spite of our individual and collective 'inhumanity to humanity', there is always a Light of Hope, in Love , in all of us. 'A Light having come into the world' of our Christ Conscious Awareness, where no darkness - with our faithful cooperation - will overcome it or extinguish it. Where Hope in Love and New Beginnings, always Springs Eternal. A Hope in Love which alone will always cast out our worst fears. Above and beyond the importance of your talented writing, with 'mathematical certitude'. May I encourage you, to reiterate and express the same, with even more of the prophetic, the proverbial, the poetic and the intuitive. To move and motivate 'Hearts and Souls', at a far deeper level. To reach those multitudes, bound in todays 'Valley of Indecision' of 'realism and cynircism'. Maintain your Prophetic Voice. Regards Michael J.Wood OM. oneinchristfellowship.com

Michael J.Wood OM 25 August 2017

Similar articles

Draconian citizenship mindset means no one's safe

Fatima Measham | 06 July 2017

Peter DuttonThe Guardian has revealed that two men holding dual Australian citizenship were sent to Christmas Island under section 501 of the Migration Act. The law enables the minister to detain or deport non-citizens who fail the 'character test'. The detention of these citizens was without question unlawful. The error was identified and they were released. It looks like a happy ending, but you'd have to squint hard.

Awaiting the Referendum Council in NAIDOC Week

Frank Brennan | 04 July 2017

NAIDOC Week 2017 posterIt is no disrespect to those Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders gathered at Uluru to say that now is the time for the report of the Referendum Council to be scrutinised by our national politicians, and that our elected leaders should pay special heed to the observations of those Indigenous members of the federal parliament who have offered considered reflections on the way forward. In particular, our elected representatives should have regard to the views of Patrick Dodson who is now Bill Shorten's Shadow Assistant Minister for Indigenous Affairs and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders.

Bookending Australia's history

Andrew Hamilton | 12 July 2017

Colonising AustraliaModern Australian history is bookended by the arrival of white settlers in which Indigenous Australians were expelled to the margins, and by the arrival of people seeking protection who were also expelled to the margins. Between these bookends lie the events, the people, the relationships, the enterprises and the experiences that compose the story of Australia. The bookends, though, are a bit shonky: not ideal for supporting proudly the heft of the history that lies between them. They need fixing.

The manor and the workhouse in modern Australia

Andrew Hamilton | 05 July 2017

Etching of the poor in Dickensian EnglandA regular feature in Australian politics is the attempt to save money by penalising people who are struggling with life. It is usually accompanied by disparagement of the groups who are targeted. The strategy has a long history that provides a context. In 19th century England, a system was established that would encourage people to seek work by deterring them from seeking help. Central to this was the establishment of workhouses where the conditions would be more unpleasant than in any form of work.

RIP David Passi, last surviving Mabo plaintiff

Frank Brennan | 26 June 2017

David Passi on Thursday IslandAnglican priest, traditional landowner and land rights campaigner David Passi has died. He was the last surviving plaintiff in the historic Mabo decision. A year after the Mabo decision I travelled to the Torres Strait and met James Rice and Passi, the two successful litigants in the case. Returning by boat to the mainland from the island of Mer in the Murray Islands, the waters of the Torres Strait were exceedingly calm.