A- A A+

Black clown's 'house slave' awakening

Megan Graham |  04 July 2017

Monsieur Chocolat (M) Director: Roschdy Zem. Starring: Omar Sy, James Thierrée. 119 minutes

With 1.9 million tickets sold in France, Monsieur Chocolat is a bold period drama which takes a brutal snapshot of racial issues in the country around the turn of the 20th century.

Rafael Padilla (played here by Sy), who was most famously known as Chocolat the clown, was the first black performer to rise to fame in France. As this film shows, it was a difficult role to play at a time when non-Anglo French were either hidden away or publicly shamed.

Public shaming accompanies his rise to fame and fortune as part of a 'clown blanc and Auguste' duo — a popular theatrical device wherein the Auguste (usually black-faced) clown plays dummy to a white clown of higher intelligence who inflicts hilarious acts upon Auguste.

Experimental circus artist George Foottit (played by Charlie Chaplin's grandson, Thierrée) comes up with the routines, playing the clown blanc role expertly. It isn't long before the duo has a strong following, and the act takes Padilla from working at a lacklustre circus in the countryside — acting the absurd cannibal 'Nigger King Kalanka' to scare white people and their children — to the grandiose Nouveau Cirque in Paris. Virtually overnight, Padilla finds himself with more money and fame than he ever imagined.

And yet the differences between his King Kalanka and clown Auguste roles are far fewer than Padilla initially imagines. What he gains in applause, money, celebrity and romantic conquests, he loses in self-respect — a realisation that comes into sharp focus when, thanks to a cruel former employer, he is thrown in jail. (While Padilla managed to escape slavery — his father was a house slave in Cuba — he remained 'undocumented' and constantly terrified of being locked up.)

Padilla spends a week in prison where, amid the torture and racial abuse, he listens to the thoughts of a black revolutionary who was continually being locked up for his unrepentant stance on race issues. Padilla's continued exploitation comes coldly into view — while he is being paid better for it, he is still being used to attract crowds who like to see a black man kicked around the stage by a white man.

Omar Sy in Monsieur ChocolatMalcolm X famously delineated two types of slave — the 'house Negro' and the 'field Negro' (now commonly referred to as 'house slave and field slave'). Although a 'house slave' is closer to their oppressor and receives special privileges, they are still a slave. The 'field slave' meanwhile is separated from the oppressor and is therefore more able to be awakened and revolt.


"His crystal-clear vision of the truth of his oppressor gave him agency."


Chocolat in his role as Auguste seems to be just another kind of house slave. Despite his success he is still maligned and at the mercy of masters: Foottit, Nouveau Cirque, an overwhelmingly racist audience and government. While rubbing shoulders with the rich and famous, he is routinely denigrated, by offhand comments, by advertisements portraying him as a monkey. Attention, he learns, is not the same as respect.

By contrast, when he was still a humble performer in the French countryside, his body language, and his humour at the illogic racism he encountered, indicated his relative freedom. He even toyed with common prejudices for his own amusement. His crystal-clear vision of the truth of his oppressor gave him agency.

Monsieur Chocolat also sends a message about the nature of fame, and the experience of being used up by a voracious audience and thrown away. This can happen in all forms of popular entertainment; think of the Indigenous Australian or African-American sportspeople whose talents have been exploited, without that translating into meaningful respect for the individual's race and culture.

Padilla died in poverty in 1917. But his legacy has enjoyed renewed interest thanks to Monsieur Chocolat. Ahead of the film's opening, the mayor of Paris unveiled a plaque commemorating the clown on a building where he used to perform. A film which tackles such issues so honestly is important not only for France as a multicultural nation, but for viewers in any country with a dark story of racial injustice.


Megan GrahamMegan Graham is a Melbourne based writer.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Similar articles

Search for the meaning of afterlife

Tim Kroenert | 13 July 2017

C is waiting for something; for the meaning of his truncated life, perhaps, and of his marriage to M, to become clear. Divorced from linear perceptions of time, he rushes into the future, to witness the cityscape that replaces the suburban neighbourhood; and into the past, where he views the aftermath of the massacre of a colonial family. Amid this in-folding of time, and the evidence of death and transience, the partygoer's nihilistic prognostications echo fiercely. But they do not satisfy the truth-seeking C.

A sensitive view of high school gay romance

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 29 June 2017

Some films seem custom made for the high school English curriculum. First Girl I Loved should be essential viewing and a conversation starter for teenagers and their parents, for its sensitive and authentic exploration of the lived experiences of young people coming to terms with their sexuality in a high school context.

The Lady Macbeth of Northumberland

Tim Kroenert | 21 June 2017

Catherine arrives a new bride, with husband Alexander, to take up residence in his luxurious rural home. Quickly we get a sense of how little control she has over her destiny. Alexander demands she remain inside the house at all times; when one evening she wishes to go to bed early, her father-in-law orders her to remain awake for her husband. In the life of the household, she is merely an attractive object. Yet like her Shakespearean forebear, she is not averse to manipulation and violence in pursuit of her goals.

Who killed Whitney Houston?

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 14 June 2017

Running parallel to this is Houston's intimate, long-time friendship with Robyn Crawford. Broomfield stops short of characterising it as romantic; others do not, and space is given to rumination about the difficulties of being a black, gay woman. In any case, the friendship sparks tension with Brown, and disapproval from Cissy. Crawford's abrupt departure from the tour is another turning point. In Broomfield's thesis, Houston's drug habit is a reaction to these various threats to her authenticity.

Raising feminist men in 1970s America

Tim Kroenert | 07 June 2017

Abbie introduces Jamie to the paired liberating movements of punk rock and second-wave feminism. Both lead to illuminating experiences, from his first rock concert, use of alcohol, and kiss, to being beaten for casting aspersions on a peer's grasp of female sexual anatomy. His relationship with Julie on the other hand provides a difficult counterpoint. His peevish concern over her promiscuity is largely possessive; his theoretical understanding of women's agency falling down in the face of adolescent hormones.