A- A A+

Mothers of the missing still marching in Argentina

Antonio Castillo |  11 May 2017


It began 40 years ago on an autumn day — on 30 April 1977 — when 14 mothers gathered in Buenos Aires' Plaza de Mayo, in the city's central square. They were seeking an audience with the military authorities.

Mothers of Plaza de MayoThey wanted to ask the whereabouts of their abducted children. 'Where are our children?' was a question that metamorphosed into a brave act of political resistance and defiance against the brutal 1976–1983 Argentinean military dictatorship.

In Plaza de Mayo, right in front of Argentina's pink government house, the mothers waited and waited for an answer, until the police forced them to move away.

'Circulate,' the threatening, baton-wielding police shouted at them. And so they did. They moved. And then, they marched slowly counter-clockwise in a line, two abreast around the Plaza's white obelisk, built to mark the first anniversary Argentina's independence from Spain in 1816. They have been performing this act of defiance since then, every Thursday at 3:30pm.

The Mothers of Plaza de Mayo, one of the most potent movements of resistance against tyranny, was born that day. They began wearing white headscarves with their children's names embroidered on them, and carrying huge hand-made placards with the smiling faces of their missing children. Others hang small photographs around their necks.

In a speech, Hebe de Bonafini, a historical leader of the Mothers, once said: 'Our missing children gave us birth.' When a shroud of silence wrapped the frightened Argentinean society, these brave women raised their voices. They became — as Argentinean philosopher Rubén Dri put it — 'a sign of life in the face of the project of death carried out by the dictatorship'. And it was indeed a terrifying project of death. It is estimated that 30,000 were killed or went 'missing'. Few bodies were ever found.

While the military repression was massive and generalised, young people became the preferred targets. They became enemies of the state. Many years ago an Argentinian journalist sent shivers down my spine when he told me the military effectively 'annihilated a whole a generation of young Argentineans'.

While the military machinery of death was in full operation, one by one new Mothers joined the movement until it became a single unified voice with a single demand: 'They were taken alive, alive we want them returned.'


"Three of the Mothers were abducted, tortured and thrown alive into the Atlantic sea on one of the dictatorship's infamous 'death flights' — the practice of drugging opponents and dropping them alive from aircraft."


And in a symbolic act, described by the Mothers as 'socialisation of maternity', the placards with the photos of their smiling missing children were swapped between them. 'We don't fight for our own children, it is a collective struggle for those 30,000 who disappeared, they are all our children,' they declared. They constructed themselves as the mothers of all those who disappeared.

They were mainly working class women. One of them was Azucena Villaflor. She was one of the founders of the movement. She was the one who suggested Plaza de Mayo be the public canvas for their act of resistance. One of Villaflor's sons, Néstor, had been abducted together with his wife Raquel Mangin.

At the end of 1977 she, along with two other Mothers, Esther Ballestrino and María Ponce del Bianco, became victims of the dictatorship. They were abducted, tortured and thrown alive into the Atlantic sea on one of the dictatorship's infamous 'death flights' — the practice of drugging opponents and dropping them alive from aircraft. The body of Villaflor washed up on a beach in 2015. Her ashes were buried at the foot of the Plaza de Mayo obelisk. The bodies of the two other mothers were never found.

Many of the young Argentineans abducted were pregnant women. Some were executed with their children inside their wombs. Many others were perversely spared until they gave birth; then the mothers were killed and the newborns became war booty. They were given away. Many ended up in the hands of military officers. It is estimated that 500 children were kidnapped or born in detention.

The search for the stolen children has been a painful and slow mission for the Mothers and for the 'sister organisation' called the Grandmothers of Plaza de Mayo. Last 26 April, just four days before the commemoration of the Mothers' four decades of struggle, child '122' was found and identified. He was a boy. He was born inside the walls of the ESMA — La Escuela Superior de Mecánica de la Armada or the Higher School of Mechanics of the Navy — a horrifying den of imprisonment, torture and death used by the military.

The end of the military regime and the punishment of those behind these crimes have been the greatest achievements of their struggle; a struggle that has still not ended. Elderly and frail, many nonagenarian and wheelchair bound, they keep on marching every Thursday at 3:30pm. They demand the government of right wing Mauricio Macri open 'all the archives of the dictatorship'. This is a fundamental demand in a time when Argentina's historical memory is — as the Mothers said during last 30 April's commemoration — 'under threat'. The mothers have never forgotten their lost children or grandchildren.


Antonio CastilloAntonio Castillo is a Latin American journalist and Director of the Centre for Communication, Politics and Culture, CPC, RMIT University, Melbourne-Australia.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Similar articles

Ahok is innocent and Indonesia needs him

Pat Walsh | 15 May 2017

Basuki Tjahaja PurnamaDid he denounce Islam as 'evil' like the American evangelist Franklin Graham? Did he publicly denounce God as 'stupid' like Stephen Fry? On the contrary. Ahok is deeply respectful of Islam and has many Muslim supporters. The affair has done a serious disservice to Indonesia, presenting it as fanatical, racist and sectarian. While these perceptions are unfair, the affair also reveals some aspects of contemporary Indonesia that are obscured by Canberra's often lavish praise of our important neighbour.

Artificial womb has many possible futures

Kate Galloway | 09 May 2017

Lamb foetus in artifical wombOne of the big science stories in the last month has been the invention of an artificial womb. The device has successfully assisted a number of lamb foetuses to term, and scientists are hopeful it will also assist premature human babies. What a wonderful development, to alleviate the health complications for those tiny babies and reduce the heartache for their parents. But the potential of the invention does not stop there. Like all tools, humans could choose to put it to use in ways that are good or bad.

Egypt and Ethiopia river wars be dammed

1 Comment
Tuhimi Akebet | 16 May 2017

Grand Ethiopian Renaissance DamThe building of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile by a major Italian construction company remains a source of tension between Ethiopia and Egypt. Egypt sees the Nile as its sole source for the survival of its population and, historically, has seen itself as its sole natural guardian. Ethiopia argued in response, on the basis of unseen studies, that there would be no reduction of water downstream. Both are mindful of the disastrous war they waged against each other early in the 19th century.

Unis share blame for profit motive funding model

Binoy Kampmark | 03 May 2017

University of SydneyFor various reasons, 'free' education in Australia has been qualified by HECS, which actually serves to wedge the liquid incentive of government and educational institutions on the one hand with the need for students to obtain affordable education on the other. Even that balance is now under threat, with a pre-budget announcement suggesting cuts to university funding and increasing costs to student degrees are in the offing. Universities are far from blameless in the present distorted funding model.

East Timorese heroes of Australian wars

Susan Connelly | 24 April 2017

Australian commando in East TimorFearful of the southward thrust of the Japanese, the Australian government entered East Timor against the wishes of its Portuguese colonisers. The move was not to protect the Timorese, but to thwart possible attacks on Australia. A band of intrepid Australian soldiers, never numbering more than 700, successfully held off thousands of Japanese in Timor, but only because they had the support of the local people. Between 40,000 and 60,000 Timorese died as a result of Japanese reprisals.