A- A A+

Penetrating the cult of secrecy and abuse

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert |  14 March 2017


The Family (PG). Director: Rosie Jones. 98 minutes

In the alpine region of Victoria's north-east lies Lake Eildon, a massive embankment dam that feeds the local Goulburn Murray Irrigation District. It is a popular destination for holidaymakers and water sports enthusiasts. Its dark waters conceal the long submerged gold mining township of Darlingford; for years, too, during the 1960s and 70s, they listened in on the closely guarded secrets of the notorious apocalyptic sect, The Family, one of whose compounds crouched on the rim of one of its western bays.

Rosie Jones' documentary about The Family returns repeatedly to the lake, cinematographer Jaems Grant's camera plying its misty, rippling surface, which is pierced here and there by the skeletal arms of drowned trees. These images, with an elegiac piano-and-strings score by Amanda Brown, establish an eerie atmosphere. They also stand as a recurring metaphor for the life of a sect whose manmade ideology mashed Christian and Eastern philosophies with conspiracy theory paranoia, and whose motto was 'Unseen, unheard, unknown'.

Jones has assembled a wealth of archival 'home video' footage and an intriguing mixture of voices that illuminate the past's shadowy corners. They include former sect members, traumatised children grown to troubled adulthood; police officers who in the late 1980s made it their life-sapping mission to penetrate the sect; journalists who investigated The Family; and even, intriguingly, a present day member, one of a small handful who remain in thrall to the sect's charismatic founder and self-proclaimed Christ-figure, Anne Hamilton-Byrne.

Children from The Family sectHamilton-Byrne's husband Bill died in 2001; she is today 95 and resident of a dementia ward. The cult's leaders thus remain frustratingly opaque, even as the film details the extent of their abuses, and as recordings of her voice float across the soundscape with fervent utterings of faith and love.


"The 28 or so children who passed through that Eildon home endured routine beatings, starvation diets, and 'treatment' with LSD."


Under their care, and that of the various 'aunties and uncles' of the sect, the 28 or so children who passed through that Eildon home endured routine beatings, starvation diets, and 'treatment' with LSD at ages, one former member claims, as young as eight.

Some were the offspring of sect members, most of whom were middle class professionals; others were illegally adopted with the help of members in the medical profession. Most of this detail has been known for years, including from media coverage at the time, and from the 1995 memoir Unseen Unheard Unknown, by former 'sect child' Sarah Moore, writing as Sarah Hamilton-Byrne. (Moore, who died last year, was instrumental in bringing the sect to the attention of Victoria Police in the 1980s; Jones' film is dedicated to her.)

The power of Jones' film then comes from bringing us the faces and voices of the victims in the present day, juxtaposed with archival footage of their police interviews; to hear in their words and see in their manner the ongoing trauma of those experiences. It is a timely and illuminating exploration of the impacts of child abuse, arriving during a period when many of our Australian institutions, religious and otherwise, have been facing the probing spotlight of a royal commission for behaviour that was equally as secretive, and traumatic.


Tim KroenertTim Kroenert is editor of Eureka Street.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

tim. what a killer opening to your review. Beautful writing about a decidedly ugly episode in Melbourne's very recent history. I too saw this film and was as enthralled (by the scope and breadth of the footage and the cinematography) and appalled (by the subject matter) as you.

jenv 16 March 2017

Similar articles

The time-traveller's strife

Tim Kroenert | 22 March 2017

All stories that deal with time travel will come up against paradoxes. Generally the success of the story will come down to how capably these paradoxes are dealt with, and how consistently with the story's internal logic. Otto Bloom turns on the concept of time as an extension of the physical dimensions. If time is as tangible as physical space, then all events in time are occurring simultaneously. That we perceive time as moving in a particular direction is a feature of our human consciousness.

Interracial romance's antidote to cultural appropriation

Tim Kroenert | 08 March 2017

Mildred would later say of Frank that 'he always took care of me'. Yet this telling of the story shows a more mutual exchange of strength and support than such a statement might imply. The Lovings' entanglement with the state of Virginia would ultimately lead to constitutional change in favour of interracial marriage, and Loving portrays Ruth as the main agent of the battle. At a time when cultural appropriation has become much talked about, this film by a white filmmaker shows a different way.

Faith is torture in Scorsese's Silence

Tim Kroenert | 22 February 2017

It is the story of two 17th century Portuguese Jesuits who travel to Japan to locate their former mentor, who is said to have renounced his faith, and to spread Catholicism. They find the local Christian populations have been driven underground, under threat of torture and execution. The lesson they come to learn against this fraught backdrop is that the living out of religious faith and the strengths and limitations of ordinary humanity cannot be considered in isolation from each other.

Space race saga's Black history through White eyes

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 14 February 2017

There's a gag about sitting in the back of the bus, the realities of segregation dismissed with a giggle; references to university sit-ins and firebombings come via the eyes of a cartoonishly earnest character. Meanwhile the White characters are either the object of contrived sympathy, or too thinly drawn to invoke genuine menace. Accusations of 'cultural appropriation' might be uncharitable, but the short shrift given to the real, continuing hardships of Black experience raises questions about objectives and authenticity.

Fences and co. fight back against Oscars racial bias

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 08 February 2017

The Academy, it seems, has listened. After the #whiteoscars furore of past years, three of this year's Oscar nominees for Best Picture, Moonlight, Fences, and Hidden Figures, are films with predominantly (if not entirely) Black casts, and focused on the experiences of Black characters. Cast and crewmembers from all three have been nominated in various categories. To be fair, all three films would have demanded attention, with or without the recent controversy around awards season racial bias.