A- A A+

Empathy for Russia after Trump's ascent

6 Comments
Justin Glyn |  14 November 2016

 

We do not know what the contours of a Trump presidency will look like. Nevertheless, I think that there is already one important lesson we can draw from what has come as a huge surprise to most people: the need for empathy to supplement information.

xxxxxWe talk, glibly, of 'information technology'. The internet and the power of mass computing mean that those lucky enough to have access to a computer can, with the click of a mouse, discover the details of everything from the Investiture Controversy to the Krebs cycle. Those who run security services can, as Edward Snowden and others have told us, tell you much more besides — the contents of your emails, who you spoke to last week or who is slated for annihilation by drone.

Yet all this information can actually be downright misleading. The fact that there is just so much of it sloshing around means we have to filter it somehow. Human nature being what it is, we tend to live in an echo chamber, only listening to the news we like.

Of course, to some degree it was ever thus: Greens voters don't usually buy the Tele and One Nation supporters rarely read The Guardian. With the rise in electronic media, however, this tendency is magnified: by choosing what you see and hear, you never have to know what your neighbour thinks. That way, you also don't have to talk to them, have your views challenged or grow in understanding.

While this impoverishes individuals, cutting them off from others, breeding intolerance and stifling the healthy debates which were supposed to be part of the essence of free speech in a democratic society, it also has lethal effects on the political stage.

The US election serves as Exhibit A. Because they listened only to like-minded people, pollsters, pundits and pollies were blindsided by a Trump victory and are now scrambling to formulate a response.

Yet the deep-seated sense of alienation of people laid off in a globalising world and suffering from economic austerity has been visible (for those who would see it) for years: in the Greek protests against austerity, the rise of Berlusconi and later Grillo in Italy, the Brexit vote, the rise of One Nation and now Trump. Yet somehow, each of these things was always regarded as just one more aberration.

How quickly we forget the desperation of millions when they felt discarded and humiliated in the Europe of the 1920s and 1930s and the way in which unscrupulous tyrants harnessed them. Yet, in our defence, who knew? 

 

"If a failure of empathy marks our understanding of internal politics, its effects are magnified, with even worse results, in the international arena."

 

In an age where interception of communications makes the STASI look like rank amateurs, no-one was listening to the little people. Their world was so far removed from the circles of the good and the great (for whom globalisation was all roses and sunshine) upon which the media focussed that no-one paid real attention to the fear and anger — preferring to mock the uncouth demagogue who, like others before him, saw a shortcut to power by channelling that hurt and hate and focusing it on his preferred targets.

If a failure of empathy marks our understanding of internal politics, its effects are magnified, with even worse results, in the international arena. A classic example is Russia. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, the West has failed to take Russian interests seriously. They lost the Cold War, after all, and should now be expected to take their medicine quietly. Ironically, Vladimir Putin rules using the same constitution which the west's drunken darling Boris Yeltsin imposed on Russia after turning artillery on parliament in 1993. Its provisions then were hailed as a triumph of democracy. The feelings of a beaten and fleeced people were not regarded as worth noting.

What the west sees as militaristic revanchism by a mad dictator is seen by many Russians as an attempt at regaining self-respect. Rightly or wrongly, the encounter in Syria and America's recent threats to shoot down Russian aircraft there have led to nuclear warfare civil defence drills in Russia. These fears are stoked by western talk of nuclear primacy over Russia and actual NATO military build-up on its borders as well as memories of past encirclement and invasion by everyone from Prussian knights to Hitler.

Again, I stress that I endorse neither the Russian government nor its point of view. However, knowing that the other side has a point of view and what it is is vital in avoiding miscalculations. You don't get a second chance with nuclear weapons.

Empathy saves lives and, who knows, maybe all life.

 


Justin GlynFr Justin Glyn SJ is studying canon law in Canada. Previously he practised law in South Africa and New Zealand and has a PhD in administrative and international law.

 



Comments

Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Well said, Justin. Of perhaps better, "Well written". Power to your arm.

Brendan Byrne 15 November 2016

Sorry but this sounds awfully like appeasement to me

Maureen clarke 16 November 2016

Maureen clarke : "Sorry but this sounds awfully like appeasement to me ". To an attuned ear it might sound more like a caution against over-reacting, which could lead to disaster

Robert Liddy 16 November 2016

The collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War should have seen Russia and the West come together. However at the time of German reunification, George Bush Snr apparently told or indicated to Russia that there would be no eastward expansion of NATO (there is some dispute as to what exactly was said). Bill Clinton then reneged on this apparent agreement, which put an end to any chance of Russia and the West becoming allies. In fact it only confirmed Russian distrust of the West. The US has been carrying the burden of the military defence of the West since WW2, and Trump wants Europe and its other allies to contribute more. As Trump will be inheriting a $20 trillion debt, his demands are fair enough. Trump also seems to get along reasonably well with Putin which augurs well for the future.

Ross Howard 17 November 2016

Russia is the home of the largest of the sister churches to the Roman Catholic Church. If we are going to ask God at every Mass to "look not on our sins but on the faith of your church", perhaps at least the Catholics in the Christian West should look not on the sins of Putin but on the faith of the Russian Orthodox Church as the reason for encouraging honest relations with Russia.

Roy Chen Yee 18 November 2016

Thanks Justin. A great admonition to either know or respect our adversary as Chinese wisdom always suggested. But to understand the whole of the population not just the writing elites. Just noticed on the Guardian that there were 50,000 hate tweets in the month following the murder of Jo Cox. What were they feeling and what were they thinking and who listened to them despite their ugly utterances?

Michael D. Breen 27 November 2016

Similar articles

Left doesn't own the fight against racism

8 Comments
Irfan Yusuf | 15 November 2016

Islamic gathering, historic illustrationCultural totalitarianism, embodied in Trump in the US and Hanson in Australia, is a major injustice of our age. To fight it effectively, we have to enter into coalitions with those whose opinions we otherwise find distasteful. An anti-racism rally with only leftwing speakers is not going to make as big an impact as one with speakers across the spectrum. To insist the fight against racism is necessarily a leftwing issue is in some ways its own form of cultural bigotry.


Understanding Trump the businessman President

16 Comments
David James | 10 November 2016

Donald TrumpThe first step for a business person is to make the sale, usually by over-promising and tapping into the emotional triggers of the customer. That is what Trump did. Over and over, he assured everyone that electing him would be 'fantastic'; he would deliver; customer-value is in the bag. The next step, once the sale is made, is for a hard financial logic to be applied. Trump's hype will be, at the very least, toned down. Once the customer has coughed up, business people typically become extremely pragmatic.


Progressives must stand firm in Trump's shadow

19 Comments
Fatima Measham | 10 November 2016

Donald TrumpIt didn't take long for me and other Filipino friends to be asked 'How do we Americans deal with this?' There is nothing soothing to say. Trump is not Duterte, of course, and there are differences in governance and law enforcement that (as yet) better protect Americans. But what I know is it is not the office that makes the person presidential. It is a waste of time to expect Trump to change. There will be no post-election unity, despite the conciliatory noises being made. And yet there is no choice but to endure.


Trust or bust after shattering US election campaign

21 Comments
Andrew Hamilton | 09 November 2016

Broken eggThe US election, to no one's regret, is now over. It remains to wish Donald Trump well as he prepares to take up the office of president. It is tempting to see Hillary Clinton as Humpty Dumpty and ask how she can pick up the pieces of her life, when tarnished and wearied by a campaign so full of personal abuse, revelations of tawdry behaviour and a lack of grace. Yet it is not Clinton that lies broken at the foot of the wall. It is the polity of the US, shown to be bereft of the trust necessary for national wellbeing.


A new generation of remembrance

8 Comments
Kate Mani | 10 November 2016

Group crossing no-man's landIt's 9pm but the setting sun shows no sign of repose as it beams down across the vast wheat fields of Fromelles. The line between land and sky blurs as yellowing crops align with the sun's reach. On the other side of no man's land, a pale moon is just visible. Straight ahead a rough path through the wheat leads to the German lines. It's down this path that I file with the Friends of the 15th Brigade, descendants of the soldiers who fought here 100 years ago in the 59th and 60th AIF battalions.