A- A A+

Islamophobic racism is a blunt weapon

5 Comments
Rachel Woodlock |  14 November 2016

 

It is an enduring personal tragedy that I can never think of 'zinger' responses to hurled insults until having ruminated and turned them over in my mind for some time. It is, perhaps, the effect of living the intellectual, academic life that I must cogitate on a statement before I feel ready to supply a well-reasoned reply.

Face plastered with Islamophobic labelsUnfortunately for me, the white male hoon in his 20-year-old unroadworthy car has long-since roared away from the traffic lights after shouting out some unremarkable and unoriginal statement: 'Go back to where you came from you [expletive] terrorist Arab.' Kilometres later I'm ready to shout out: 'I would, but Doncaster East is becoming way too pricey for the likes of me.'

But how come an ordinary white Aussie sheila with some five- or six-generations worth of Anglo and Celtic colonial settler heritage on both sides might be subject to such racist barbs in 21st century Australia? A delicately-pinned scarf and a long dress signal to every testosterone-overloaded yobbo that I'm a Muslim. And to an unsophisticated racist, all Muslims are Arabs and all Arabs are terrorists.

If I took off my headscarf it would be problem solved; I'm back to being a perfectly acceptable white Australian woman, unless I reveal my religious identity in other ways — in the food I do and don't consume or the prayers I perform every day even when I'm away from home.

Most other Muslims don't have that luxury. Skin colour, names, accents, and other embodiments of belonging to historically-Muslim racial groups indelibly mark them as Other.

Prejudice is a power relationship that places one group of individuals at the top of a hierarchy of privileges against which all other groups are negatively compared to varying degrees. Thus, disability, skin colour, ancestral heritage, education-level, gender, sexual-orientation, religious adherence, socioeconomic status, refugee status and more are all barriers that hinder a person's access to privilege. Imagine being a poor, black, African, disabled Muslim lesbian refugee!

This is why racism is not only for those at the top of the hierarchy — historically, the WASP male. To challenge the prejudices of those lower down in the privilege hierarchy through, say, education or socioeconomic status, via mechanisms like affirmative action, is to endanger the level of privilege they tenuously possess. Which brings me back to Islamophobia.

Islamophobic racism is a blunt weapon. It is aimed just as devastatingly at non-Muslims who look a bit too Muslim: brown Sikhs and Hindus wearing turbans, hirsute Greek Orthodox priests, and Arab Christians.

 

"While Richard Dawkins is correct when he points out that Islam is a religion not a race, in the real world Islamophobic racism indiscriminately trawls and catches those merely appearing to be Muslim."

 

Earlier this year, a woman sitting in her American Airlines plane seat next to a bearded man became worried about the strange scribbles he was jotting down and called the flight attendant to complain of feeling sick. After she was taken off the plane, she revealed she was not sick, but worried the man might be a terrorist.

It turned out he was an Italian University of Pennsylvania economics professor who was solving differential equations for a paper on menu costs. He was taken off the plane for investigation, but authorities later allowed him back on. Still, even the appearance of writing Arabic and giving a cold-shoulder response to a nosey seatmate was enough to trigger an Islamophobic response in this woman.

This is why Islamophobia overlaps on many levels with racism, because while Richard Dawkins is correct when he points out that Islam is a religion not a race, in the real world Islamophobic racism indiscriminately trawls and catches those merely appearing to be Muslim. It is not the classical racism of the Ku Klux Klan, in the 'your skin colour makes you inherently inferior to me' sense of the word. The newer forms of racism work more subtly.

If your genome puts you in a group that is historically Muslim-majority — and here we are talking mostly Arabs, Africans and Asians, albeit some Europeans too — or even if you look like you might belong to one of those groups, Islamophobic racism encodes you as belonging to an inferior culture, which leads to experiences of discrimination, vilification and at the pointy end, violent hate-crimes.

What is the solution? I am convinced racism (whether Islamophobic, anti-Semitic or in any other form) is a type of mind virus, a disordered way of thinking. The long-term cure is education, but in the short term, with a worldwide pandemic enflamed by the current political landscape, we must each of us take strong measures to protect ourselves and others. To challenge the virus whenever and wherever it presents itself: on the playground, in the workplace, in letters to media, among our family and friends, and especially whether or not it immediately affects ourselves, because as Pastor Martin Niemöller might write today: 'First they came for the Muslims ... '

 


Rachel WoodlockDr Rachel Woodlock is an expat Australian academic and writer living in Ireland.

 



Comments

Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

My response: If the British invaders will return the ancestral lands of my Irish great-grandfather I will gladly go.

Gary Dargan 16 November 2016

The appreciation of self as different is a built in human trait as old as Humanity. Racism is born of that and is also a basic human trait. It is not going to change when human beings are not prepared to change to fit into the society in which they choose to live. Islamophobia is no different from the Westophobia of many Muslims, the Anglophobia of many Asians or any other racially based phobia.. All are indulgent human weaknesses to which we are all prone at times.

john frawley 16 November 2016

I love your picture. To a very old lady like me, you look exactly like a Catholic nun, strictly speaking a religious sister. How times change and how ridiculous are ignorant prejudices!

Sheelah Egan 16 November 2016

"Christophobia" is exceedingly more serious than Islamophobia. World-wide, Christians have far more to fear from Muslim violence than the reverse. See how many Christians are murdered or have violence committed against them here: https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks/christian-attacks.aspx. How many of the people associated with the following web-site would remain alive or free if they were in Islamic countries: http://www.centerforinquiry.net/secularislam/ ? Violent hate-crimes by Muslims are common. See what they do in Pakistan, for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Pakistan#.27Islamist.27_violence_against_Christians or in Bangladesh: https://www.christianfreedom.org/christianity-growing-in-bangladesh-despite-increased-persecution/ Or read the following articles (SMH and ABC): http://www.smh.com.au/comment/these-crimes-have-everything-to-do-with-islam-20150111-12lxmn.html 19 out of 20 organisations listed as terrorist organisations by the Australian Government are Islamic: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-02-25/fact-file3b-five-facts-about-terrorism-in-australia/6226086 All these facts speak for themselves. It is a fact that people react to violence in different ways. One way is to hate the perpetrator of violence. Another is to react in equal measure. Islamophobia is a rational response to the factual evidence of the amount of violence perpetrated by people claiming to be Muslim against those who do not. Christians are called to love one another, even their enemies. It is clear that many Muslims in many Islamic countries see all non-Muslims as their enemies, otherwise all this violence simply would not occur. Jesus said “By their fruits you shall know them”. The highly visible fruits of Islam in the modern world demonstrably include murder of; and other violence against many others. Is Dr Woodlock proposing to re-educate all Muslims against this disordered way of thinking?

Frank S 16 November 2016

" Islamophobia is a rational response to the factual evidence of the amount of violence perpetrated by people claiming to be Muslim against those who do not." Let's not fall into the trap of using words constructed for political advantage. There is very little 'Islamophobia' in Western societies. A phobia is a derangement. Most citizens of liberal democracies do not break out in hives when they see someone who could be a Muslim. There is, however, a fair bit of Islamoscepticism in which one is q.

Roy Chen Yee 17 November 2016

Similar articles

Mediscare blame obscures government's weaknesses

5 Comments
John Warhurst | 03 October 2016

Malcolm Turnbull with Mediscare ghost cutoutThe main message of the 2016 election review delivered recently at the National Press Club by Tony Nutt, the federal director of the Liberal Party, was that Turnbull only failed to have a convincing victory because of the 'Mediscare' by the Labor Party. It is a message that deflects attention from the current and past weaknesses of the government and the prime minister. It is like a football coach who after a loss or a narrow win blames his team's performance on the dirty tactics of the opposition.


Vulnerable people must be at the heart of welfare reforms

8 Comments
Andrew Hamilton | 28 September 2016

Mother and childThere is much to welcome in the ideals spruiked in Minister Porter's proposed welfare reforms. Who could fail to be delighted if people are helped to support themselves, and the welfare bill is reduced as people no longer need support? The question left hanging is what drives these changes. Is the human welfare of our fellow Australians the goal towards which the budgetary changes are a means? Or are budgetary savings the goal to which the treatment of our fellow Australians will be a means?


Young man burned by Australia's detention hell

21 Comments
Lisa Stewart | 26 September 2016

Painting of screaming asylum seeker behind wireIn the early hours of Wednesday morning, 21 September 2016, a young asylum seeker was forcibly removed from the Maribyrnong Immigration Detention Centre. With barely time to scramble his possessions together, he was taken away, placed on a plane and, along with four others, transferred to the high security detention facility on Christmas Island. Why? Because he's done something wrong? Because he's a criminal? No. Just because that's the way we now do things here.


Aboriginal art installation quickens ancient footprints

1 Comment
Jeremy Clarke | 27 September 2016

Wiradjuri/Kamilaroi artist Jonathan Jones' sculptureWiradjuri/Kamilaroi artist Jonathan Jones' piece is profoundly moving. At first glance it is little more than a quirky reconfiguring of the architectural footprint of the Garden Palace that burned to the ground on 22 September 1882, taking with it a collection of precious Indigenous relics. A more informed engagement however reveals that Jones has created a provocative re-imagining and, through this, a re-membering of Australian colonial contact history which has deep resonances for today.


Indecent asylum policy damages us all

10 Comments
Samuel Dariol | 21 September 2016

Peter Dutton with blood soaked hand stands on 'the world stage' and sings 'you should do it my way'. Cartoon by Fiona KatauskasIn the last week Turnbull has lauded, as the world's best refugee policy, a system that has resettled no refugees over three years. Dutton has stated that asylum seekers will continue to be processed in Nauru for decades, and described the Australian policy, of which detention on Nauru is part, as compassionate and effective. These comments follow recent reports by NGOs Save the Children and UNICEF, as well as the Australian Human Rights Commission, on offshore detention. Both urge an end to it.