A- A A+

Cruelled by the Budget

John Falzon |  14 May 2014

This Budget is deeply offensive to the people who wage a daily battle to survive.

The government would like us to believe that this Budget is tough but fair, but for the people who struggle to make ends meet it can only be described as being tough but cruel.

There are measures in this Budget that rip the guts out of what remains of a fair and egalitarian Australia. These measures will not help people into jobs but they will force people into poverty.

You don't help young people
or older people
or people with disabilities
or single mums
into jobs
by making them poor.

You don't build people up by putting them down.

And as even the OECD acknowledges, you don't build a strong economy by increasing the level of inequality.

You don't create a strong country on the backs of the already poor.

There's nothing human or humane about humiliating people because they are outside the labour market or on its low-paid fringes.

There's nothing smart about making it unaffordable for people to see a doctor.

This government has walked away from its responsibility to its people.

It has shied away from the challenge to build a broader and more sustainable revenue base so that no one misses out on the essentials of life such as a place to live, a place to work and a place to learn.

We are not in the throes of a fiscal crisis but if we embark on this treacherous path of US-style austerity we will be staring down the barrel of a social crisis.


John FalzonDr John Falzon is Chief Executive of the St Vincent de Paul Society National Council and is author of The language of the unheard.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

As a devout Catholic who accepts Catholic social teaching, I have my own objections to the budget. It's nowhere near free market enough. And so the poor will continue to be hurt. We need to free up the labour market allow the weakest bargainers to climb onto the first rung of the ladder. Eg, abolish the draconian "Fair Work" regulations which won't allow those school kids in Terang, Vic, to happily and conveniently work 2 hours after school in a newsagency instead of 3, without coercing the boss to pay them at the next level. Give me a break! And so on. The coalition government has missed a great opportunity to radically free up the market and give the poor and vulnerable opportunities to create wealth for themselves. Australia is to a significant extent still not open for business. So much the worse for the poor.

HH 15 May 2014

As a SVP member for the Norwood Conference in S A, I fear that there will be an increase of people needing help to pay their basic Utility charges, J P K

JPKeane 16 May 2014

Sorry HH, but you ignore the clear lessons of history if you think 'Chicago School' trickle-down economics leads to anything else than vastly growing equalities in society. When you have a system and its acolytes with dollar signs for hearts, humans simply become support systems for the economy, rather than being at the centre of our concerns as the gospels tell us they should be. I am a member of vinnies and regularly visit the poor, young and old, in boarding houses in Kings Cross. Try telling them that this is a budget which doesn't go far enough, and that they need to do more heavy lifting. Particularly when many affluent people get off scot free because negative gearing, capital gains tax, trust arrangements for minimizing tax and vastly over- generous superannuation provisions are left untouched. I struggle to find anything vaguely Christian (or Catholic) in any of that. Good on you John for your forthright defence of those in need!

mick mc 16 May 2014

How will people denied the dole afford train fares for job interviews? Seniors get a $2.50 fare in Sydney, but for everyone else train and bus travel are expensive

Lee Andrews 17 May 2014

Similar articles

Eddie Mabo's legacy

Frank Brennan | 23 July 2013

Bonita Mabo with some of Eddie's descendants

'If my mob were to arrive by boat today uninvited, they would be sent to Papua New Guinea. 150 years ago, the traditional owners helped my ancestors and their fellow passengers to find safe anchorage so that they might settle here permanently calling Australia home.' Frank Brennan speaks on 'Eddie Mabo's legacy of equality, non-discrimination and agreement', Mabo Oration Response at the Playhouse, Queensland Performing Arts Centre, 21 July 2013 

Too much order with too little law 30 years on

1 Comment
Frank Brennan | 23 July 2014

'Undoubtedly there are many challenges confronting our elected leaders in dealing with violent crime and with pathological sex offenders. But long-term sustainable solutions must be based on respect for judicial independence and for the role of the legal profession.' Frank Brennan addresses the Queensland Council for Civil Liberties at The Irish Club, 175 Elizabeth St, Brisbane 8 July 2014.

Is our morality at sea with the refugees?

Frank Brennan | 11 April 2014

'We should abandon talk of taking Australia off the table. We should also abandon talk of taking the sugar off the table. The collateral damage of that is too great. The best we can do ethically and practically is to put the sugar out of reach while leaving it on the table for those who make it here with a visa or in direct flight from persecution.' Frank Brennan contributes to a Palm Sunday panel at St Michael's Uniting Church, Melbourne.

Human Rights, the national interest and the will of the people

1 Comment
Frank Brennan | 11 April 2014

'Whether or not we have a bill of rights, much of our human rights jurisprudence remains partial, failing to extend rights equally to all. Once we investigate much of the contemporary discussion about human rights, we find that often the intended recipients of rights do not include all human beings but only those with certain capacities or those who share sufficient common attributes with the decision makers. It is always at the edges that there is real work for human rights discourse to do.' Frank Brennan's Blackfriars Lecture

Too little law in Newman's Queensland

Frank Brennan | 24 February 2014

'Three decades on, Queensland once again has a premier who finds some political advantage in skewing the balance between law and order, impugning the integrity and vocation of the legal profession. He has described defence lawyers as hired guns.' Professor Frank Brennan SJ addresses the Queensland Law Society Dinner, 30 years on from his book Too Much Order with Too Little Law.